I love eggplant Parmigiana but I hate making it. It feels like I have to make multiple dishes in order to get to the final dish, and then the leftovers are kind of stodgy and heavy and not really all that good.
And then mine eyes were opened in, of all places, Amsterdam. We had the Eggplant Parmigiana of our dreams. Truly.
Our favorite watering hole also makes excellent food. We’d planned to go elsewhere our first night there but we were really tired and De Blaffende Vis is around the corner from our apartment. There was a brief language keruffle – the daily chalkboard menu listed melanzane Parmigiana, which I translated to my husband, and he immediately told the Dutch waiter he’d have the eggplant.
:::Insert blank stare:::
The word eggplant means nothing in Dutch or actually, pretty much anywhere in the world except the US, so I re-translated back to Italian. (Not that I am a linguistics whiz; I just happened to know these words.)
What was set before us didn’t look like any eggplant Parmigiana I had ever seen. It looked like lasagna and the top almost seemed burned, but I dug in anyway. Holy God, was it good. Nothing crusty and breaded and deep-fried, just lovely creamy eggplant in a fabulous sauce with deeply browned cheese on top. We ate it in record time.
I spent time trying to figure out what they did and while I’ll never know for certain, I am pretty sure the eggplant slices were roasted, then layered in a baking dish with shingles of cheese on top, and baked in a very hot oven until the cheese deeply browned.
I made a couple of stabs at it once we got home. One element that can’t be replicated is the superb eggplant grown there; it’s creamy and nearly seedless. The Graffiti variety – mottled purple and white – is a good substitute if available. Their eggplant wasn’t peeled and it wasn’t tough, but I think American eggplant needs peeling.
I also don’t use a lot of Parmigiana – heresy, I know – and instead use whatever cheeses I have on hand. Currently that’s some Dutch Gouda and English cheddar. I have found that covering the top of the eggplant with thinly sliced cheese makes for better browning than shredded cheese.
The disadvantage of this method is that you need a lot of eggplant, since roasting collapses the slices and they shrink. I figure three large eggplants or four medium for an 8″ X 11′ pan.
EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA
- 3 large or 4 medium eggplants
- olive oil
- marinara sauce
- cheese of your choice
Preheat oven to 450 degrees.
Peel eggplants and slice about 1/2″ thick – no thinner, or they will shrink down to nothing while roasting.
Generously oil a cookie sheet with olive oil. Arrange eggplant slices in a single layer (crowding is fine) and bake about 12 to 15 minutes. Flip each slice. Add a little more olive oil. Bake another 5 to 7 minutes and remove from oven.
Pour a little marinara sauce in a baking dish about 8″ X 11″. Lay slices of eggplant in dish, top with a little marinara (don’t drown them), and sprinkle with some grated cheese (not a lot). Repeat layers until all eggplant is used. Top with marinara and then lay slices of cheese on top. Cover dish with foil.
At this point the dish can be refrigerated for a day. Remove from refrigerator two hours before proceeding.
Bake covered at 375 for about 40 minutes. Remove foil and turn the broiler on. Broil the dish, watching very carefully, until cheese is browned.
This will burn the roof of your mouth as is, so let it cool about 10 minutes before serving.